Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sarah Brennan's avatar

Okay, so I’m no trained economist or trained historian for that matter, but what this article explores is what I’ve seen happen myself insofar as stifling of innovation by big business is concerned.

Some decades ago, a close acquaintance started a pest control business in Australia based on an invention for impregnated “mats” which when laid in your kitchen cupboard, for example, would kill cockroaches which set foot on them and yet could be chewed by marauding human babies without I’ll effect. Sounds good, yes? So rumour has it that a certain multinational chemical company J, based in the US, invited said acquaintance to come to the States to explore this product with a purported plan to buy him out and make him a very, very rich man. So, off he went to the US - at his own expense - for a meeting where he explained the whole invention to them and they oohed and aahed and said they’d get back to him with a fabulous offer imminently… and that’s the last he heard from them. After a year of fruitless enquiry from said acquaintance, J finally got back to him. They told him to piss off and not bother them again. They’d cracked the patent and didn’t need him anymore. Nice one, huh?

And then there’s my own experience as author and publisher of the Chinese Calendar Tales. Over 13 years starting 2007, my tiny HK publishing company publishes a series of stories by me about the animals of the Chinese zodiac, one per year, for primary school aged kids. I begin to have modest success around Asia. They’re funny and educational and kids and parents and teachers love them. There is nothing like them on the market. After @ five books have been published, I am approached by a famous US entertainment and publishing company N. They LOVE the idea! I tell them more. They are sooo excited they say. And I hear nothing from them ever again.

Within a year, a series appears on the mass market by said publisher, for kids, based on the animals of the Chinese Zodiac, one book per Zodiac animal. I only find out about it when, two years later, I find it in the library shelves of a school I’m visiting in Shanghai.

But here’s the difference. Whereas my books were set in China and included fantastic fact boxes about Chinese history and culture as well as characters including real Chinese emperors, pirates, explorers etc who interacted with each zodiac animal character in fun rhyming stories which included sophisticated language because I don’t believe in dumbing down for kids, the Nickelodeon stories were about a stereotypical little Chinese girl with glasses and buckteeth growing up - you guessed it- on a typical American farm with - you guessed it- each of the animals of the Chinese zodiac. Apart from said stereotypical little Chinese girl there wasn’t ONE SKERRICK OF INFORMATION ABOUT CHINA! You could replace each Chinese zodiac animal with a Goddamn American chicken, or cow, or pig. You get the picture. The writing was anodyne and about as intellectually challenging as a PB and J sandwich on white bread, hold the nutritional content. And when I later attempt to sell my series to another large publisher I’m told there’s no market for it - there’s already another “identical product on the market”. Nice one #2.

So, the integrity of US corporations hey? Or perhaps the words “US corporations “ and “integrity “ are oxymorons.

Now I’m not suggesting that it’s only the corporation of the US that do this. But by God do they lead the way.

But silence! What’s that I hear? Could it be the tumbrils of the carts carrying the French aristocracy to the guillotine?

Let’s wait and see…

Jennifer Fields's avatar

I love Lina Khan, everything she did / tried to do at the FTC was inspiring. Thank you for this post!

12 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?